Author: Jean Paul MBARUSHIMANA
Research Publication:
From Newsroom to Boardroom:
Exploring Factors and Impacts of Career Shift from Journalism to Public Relations and Communication in Rwanda
Abstract
The shift of journalists from newsrooms into public relations (PR) and communication has become an important feature of contemporary communication labor markets. Although international scholarship has examined journalists’ occupational mobility, limited empirical attention has been given to the factors and consequences of journalists’ career shift from journalism to PR and communication in Rwanda. This study investigated the push and pull factors influencing journalists’ career shifts, assessed the effects of these movements on journalism and PR/communication, and identified strategies for improving journalist retention. The study adopted an interpretivist qualitative design and was guided by Push-Pull Theory, Social Cognitive Career Theory, and Super’s Life-Span, Life-Space Theory. Data were collected through 19 in-depth interviews involving 14 former journalists and five media managers, three focus group discussions involving seven participants, and documentary review. Data were analyzed thematically, while approximately 20% of transcripts were independently coded, producing a Cohen’s kappa coefficient of 0.82. The findings indicate that financial insecurity, inadequate or delayed remuneration, informal employment, limited social protection, difficult working conditions, restricted professional autonomy, and limited career progression were major factors pushing journalists away from newsrooms. Conversely, predictable remuneration, formal employment, social benefits, career progression, professional recognition, and improved work-life balance attracted journalists to PR and communication. The movement generated mixed sectoral effects. Journalism lost experienced human capital, institutional memory, mentorship capacity, and editorial expertise, while PR and communication organizations benefited from the transfer of journalistic competencies. The study conceptualizes this movement as skills ecosystem fluidity, whereby professional competencies move across interconnected occupational fields in response to changing employment conditions and opportunities. The study recommends stronger employment protection, improved remuneration, structured career pathways, professional development, stronger professional associations, and institutional reforms to improve journalist retention.
Keywords: Journalism, career shift, public relations & communication,
journalist mobility, skills ecosystem fluidity
1. Introduction
Journalism plays an important role in informing citizens, facilitating public debate, promoting accountability, and contributing to democratic life. The effectiveness of these functions depends substantially on the availability of competent and experienced journalists. However, journalism has experienced significant changes associated with technological transformation, changing business models, economic pressures, and evolving audience behaviour. These developments have affected journalists’ employment conditions and professional trajectories (Marjoribanks et al., 2022; Waisbord, 2019).
One important consequence of these changes is the movement of journalists from traditional newsrooms into related occupations, particularly public relations, strategic communication, corporate communication, government communication, and other institutional communication roles. This movement is facilitated by considerable overlap in the competencies required by journalism and communication. Journalists develop skills in research, writing, interviewing, editing, storytelling, media relations, content production, and audience engagement. These competencies are increasingly valuable in organizations that require professional communication services (Mbarushimana, 2026).
The relationship between journalism and public relations is nevertheless complex. Journalism is primarily concerned with independently gathering and disseminating information in the public interest, whereas public relations is generally concerned with managing relationships between organizations and their publics (Moloney, 2006; Mohd, 2018). Despite these differences, professionals can move between the two fields because of their shared communication competencies. Previous research has demonstrated that journalists who leave newsrooms frequently enter occupations in which their existing skills remain valuable (Koch & Obermaier, 2014; O’Donnell et al., 2016).
Career shift can be influenced by both negative conditions in an individual’s current occupation and attractive conditions in an alternative occupation. Financial insecurity, job instability, excessive workloads, weak career progression, and professional dissatisfaction may push individuals away from journalism. At the same time, more predictable salaries, formal employment, social protection, professional recognition, and career advancement in communication may pull journalists toward these occupations. Such dynamics correspond with the logic of Push-Pull Theory (Lee, 1966).
The Rwandan context provides an important setting for examining these dynamics. Rwanda’s media sector has undergone significant institutional and technological transformation, while communication functions have expanded within government institutions, private organizations, civil society organizations, and development agencies. As communication has become more institutionalized, employment opportunities have expanded for professionals with journalism and communication backgrounds.
At the same time, concerns regarding media-sector financial sustainability and employment conditions remain relevant. Rwanda Media Barometer reports (2021, 2024\) have identified challenges related to media profitability, financial sustainability, informal employment arrangements, and low earnings. These conditions create an environment in which experienced journalists may consider alternative professional opportunities.
The expansion of communication employment therefore creates an important labor-market relationship. Journalism produces professionals whose skills are valued by communication institutions, while some communication institutions offer employment conditions that are more attractive than those available in journalism. This creates a paradox: the skills that make journalists valuable to news organizations also make them attractive to alternative communication employers (Mbarushimana, 2026\).
The movement of journalists had important consequences for both sectors. At the individual level, career mobility also improved financial security, professional development, and quality of life. At the organizational level, however, media houses lost experienced reporters, editors, producers, and presenters. Such losses affected institutional memory, mentorship, editorial quality, and professional continuity (Mbarushimana, 2026).
The phenomenon has received limited empirical attention in Rwanda. Existing scholarship has addressed media sustainability; journalist working conditions, journalism-PR relationships, and professional mobility, but less attention has been given to the specific combination of push and pull factors shaping journalists’ movement into PR and communication, the consequences of such movement for both sectors, and the strategies that could strengthen journalist retention.
This study therefore investigated Factors and Impacts of Career Shift from Journalism to Public Relations and Communication in Rwanda. It focuses on three interconnected questions: why journalists leave journalism, what attracts them to communication, and what the movement means for both sectors. The study further develops the concept of skills ecosystem fluidity to explain the movement of professional competencies across interconnected communication occupations.
1.1 Research Questions
The study addressed the following research questions:
1\. What push and pull factors influence journalists to shift from journalism to PR and communication in Rwanda?
2\. In what ways do these career shifts affect both the journalism and PR/communication sectors?
3\. What strategies can be recommended to address the outflow of journalists from journalism to PR and communication in Rwanda?
2. Literature Review
2.1 Journalism and Occupational Precarity
Journalism has traditionally been associated with public service, professional autonomy, and social responsibility. However, technological change, changing media economics, declining advertising revenues, organizational restructuring, and increased competition have created significant challenges for the profession (Marjoribanks et al., 2022; Waisbord, 2019).
Employment insecurity is particularly important because journalism requires professionals to sustain demanding work under conditions that may not always provide adequate financial and institutional rewards. Where salaries are low or delayed, employment contracts are uncertain, and opportunities for advancement are limited, journalists may reassess the sustainability of journalism as a long-term occupation.
Research on journalists’occupational mobility suggests that newsroom exits can be influenced by organizational restructuring, job loss, dissatisfaction, and the availability of alternative employment. O’Donnell et al. (2016) found that journalists who leave newsrooms often move into occupations where their existing communication competencies remain useful.
2.2 Journalism and Public Relations/Communication
Journalism and public relations are distinct occupations, but they share a range of professional skills. Journalists research, write, interview, edit, produce content, and interact with audiences. PR professionals similarly require communication, writing, media relations, content development, audience analysis, and strategic messaging skills.
Koch and Obermaier (2014) demonstrate that journalists may hold secondary employment in public relations, reflecting the blurred boundaries between journalism and communication. Viererbl and Koch (2021) further show that movement from journalism to PR can involve changes in professional identity and occupational expectations.
The shift should therefore be examined not simply as a transition between unrelated occupations but as movement between neighbouring professional fields. This perspective is particularly relevant in contexts where communication functions are increasingly institutionalized.
2.3 Career Shift and Transferable Skills
Career trajectories have become increasingly dynamic. Fouad and Bynner (2008) argue that contemporary careers frequently involve occupational shifts rather than linear progression within a single profession.
Journalists are particularly well positioned for communication-related mobility because their professional training produces transferable skills. Journalism education and newsroom experience develop writing, research, storytelling, interviewing, editing, media monitoring, public speaking, and audience-engagement competencies.
The transferability of these competencies produced both opportunities and challenges. For individuals, mobility may provide improved employment conditions. For journalism organizations, however, repeated movement resulted in loss of experienced human capital (Mbarushimana, 2026).
2.4 Journalism and Communication in Rwanda
Rwanda has experienced growing institutionalization of communication functions. Government institutions, public agencies, NGOs, private organizations, and development institutions increasingly employ communication specialists and related professionals.
The study’s documentary evidence showed that job advertisements sought qualifications in journalism, communication, media studies, and related disciplines for positions including Communication Specialist, Public Information Officer, and Communication Analyst. Responsibilities included media monitoring, digital content production, stakeholder engagement, policy communication, crisis communication, public education, and strategic messaging.
These developments create a labor market in which journalists can transfer their existing skills to institutional communication roles.
2.5 Theoretical Framework
2.5.1 Push-Pull Theory
Lee’s (1966) Push-Pull Theory explains movement through factors that push individuals away from an existing environment and factors that attract them toward an alternative environment.
Applied to professional mobility, conditions such as low salaries, insecure employment, limited career progression, and poor working conditions may push journalists away from journalism. Conversely, formal employment, better remuneration, professional recognition, career advancement, and improved working conditions may attract them to PR and communication (Lee, 1966).
2.5.2 Social Cognitive Career Theory
Social Cognitive Career Theory (SCCT) emphasizes self-efficacy, outcome expectations, goals, and environmental influences in career decision-making (Lent et al., 1994\). The theory is useful for understanding how journalists assess their capabilities and future prospects.
Repeated experiences of insecurity may reduce expectations concerning long-term journalism careers, while successful transitions by colleagues and the availability of communication positions may increase, expectations that PR and communication offer better professional outcomes.
2.5.3 Super’s Life-Span, Life-Space Theory
Super’s (1980) theory views career development as a lifelong process shaped by changing roles, experiences, aspirations, and personal circumstances.
This perspective is relevant because participants’ career decisions were influenced not only by professional considerations but also by family responsibilities, financial needs, professional ambitions, and work-life balance.
Together, the three theories provide complementary explanations of journalist mobility. Push-Pull Theory explains structural pressures and attractions; SCCT explains perceptions and expectations; and Super’s theory situates career decisions within changing life circumstances (Mbarushimana, 2026).
3. Methodology
3.1 Research Design
The study adopted a qualitative research design grounded in an interpretivist paradigm. This approach was appropriate because the study sought to understand participants’ interpretations of their professional experiences and the meanings they attached to career transitions.
The study used thematic analysis to identify recurring patterns across interviews, focus group discussions, and documentary evidence.
3.2 Participants and Sampling
The study involved 26 participants. Nineteen participated in individual interviews, comprising 14 former journalists and five media managers. Seven additional participants participated in three focus group discussions.
Purposive sampling was used to identify participants with direct experience of the phenomenon. Snowball sampling was also employed because former journalists working in PR and communication were not readily identifiable through a single formal population list.
The former journalists had journalism experience and had subsequently moved into PR or communication roles. Media managers were included to provide institutional perspectives on journalist turnover and retention.
3.3 Data Collection
Data were collected through structured interviews, focus group discussions, and document review.
The interviews explored participants’ career trajectories, reasons for leaving or remaining in journalism, experiences in PR and communication, perceived sectoral effects, and recommendations for improving journalist retention.
Three focus group discussions provided opportunities for participants to discuss common experiences and compare perspectives concerning journalism and communication careers.
The documentary review examined job advertisements, public-sector employment documents, salary and employment frameworks, and Rwanda Media Barometer reports. These documents provided contextual evidence concerning employment conditions and the growing institutionalization of communication roles.
3.4 Data Analysis
The data were analyzed thematically. The researcher familiarized himself with the data, developed initial codes, identified candidate themes, reviewed and refined themes, and organized the findings around the research questions.
Approximately 20% of the transcripts were independently coded to assess coding consistency. Cohen’s kappa was calculated at 0.82, indicating substantial agreement. Triangulation across interviews, focus groups, and documentary evidence was also used to strengthen the credibility of the findings.
3.5 Trustworthiness
Trustworthiness was enhanced through triangulation, an audit trail, reflexive documentation, and the use of direct participant quotations. The researcher documented decisions related to participant recruitment, interview guides, coding, and theme development. Direct quotations were retained to ensure that interpretations remained grounded in participants’ experiences.
3.6 Ethical Considerations
Participation was voluntary, and informed consent was obtained. Participants were assured of confidentiality and anonymity. Codes such as Participant 1, Participant 2, FGD1, and M1 were used instead of participants’ names.
4. Results and Findings
4.1 Overview
The findings demonstrate that journalists’ career shift from journalism to PR and communication resulted from interacting push and pull factors. Financial insecurity, employment instability, difficult working conditions, limited career progression, and professional frustrations pushed journalists away from journalism. Conversely, improved remuneration, formal employment, social protection, career advancement, professional recognition, and work-life balance attracted them to PR and communication.
The findings further reveal contrasting effects. Journalism lost experienced human capital and mentorship capacity, while PR and communication organizations benefited from the transfer of journalistic skills. Participants nevertheless continued to recognize journalism as the foundation of many of the competencies they used in their new careers.
4.2 Push Factors Influencing Journalists to Leave Journalism
4.2.1 Financial Insecurity and Inadequate Remuneration
Financial insecurity emerged as one of the strongest push factors. Participants reported low salaries, delayed payment, unpaid work, and compensation that did not correspond with workload and professional responsibility.
Participant 1, a former journalist, who recalled experiencing “nine months without receiving a single franc, illustrated the seriousness of the problem.” This account demonstrates how prolonged financial insecurity can make journalism difficult to sustain as a career.
Other participants similarly described financial difficulties, but the evidence indicates that the problem extended beyond salary levels. Inadequate or irregular income affected participants’ ability to meet household responsibilities, save, invest in education, and plan for the future. Financial insecurity therefore emerged as both an immediate employment problem and a long-term career-retention challenge.
4.2.2 Employment Insecurity and Social Protection
Employment insecurity was another significant push factor. Participants described limited access to written contracts, pension arrangements, health insurance, and other employment benefits.
Participant 2, a former journalist, described working without such protections as “casual labor.” The statement captures the insecurity experienced when professional responsibilities are not accompanied by adequate employment protection.
The evidence suggests that formal employment was therefore an important attraction toward PR and communication. Participants were not simply looking for higher salaries; they were also seeking predictable employment arrangements and greater social security.
4.2.3 Working Conditions and Professional Autonomy
Difficult working conditions also influenced journalists’ career decisions. Participants described heavy workloads, long working hours, limited recognition, editorial pressure, and interference with journalistic work.
Participant 3, a former journalist, described the frustration of producing carefully researched stories that could not be broadcast when they conflicted with the interests of influential actors. This experience illustrates how professional autonomy and ethical concerns can contribute to dissatisfaction.
The findings therefore demonstrate that economic considerations alone cannot explain journalists’ career shifts. Professional autonomy, workplace culture, ethical conditions, and recognition were also relevant.
4.2.4 Limited Career Progression
Limited opportunities for advancement emerged as another important push factor. Participants described stagnant positions, repetitive assignments, limited specialization, and insufficient professional development.
Participant 8, a former journalist, questioned the long-term prospects of continuing to perform similar reporting assignments without a clear pathway for professional growth. This concern illustrates the importance of career progression in professional retention.
The finding suggests that journalists evaluate not only their current employment conditions but also their perceived future within the profession.
4.2.5 Professional Standards and Ethical Frustrations
Some participants expressed concerns about professional standards, inadequate training, editorial interference, and the perceived deterioration of journalism practice.
These concerns affected professional identity. Journalists who perceived a gap between the ideals of journalism and their actual working environments became more willing to consider alternative communication careers.
**4.3 Pull Factors Attracting Journalists to PR and Communication**
4.3.1 Better and more Predictable Remuneration
Improved remuneration emerged as a major pull factor. Participants reported that communication positions generally provided more reliable and, in some cases, substantially higher salaries than their previous journalism positions.
Participant 6, a former journalist, reported that the salary in communication was approximately twice what the participant had earned in journalism. The importance of this difference was not limited to income. Predictable payment enabled participants to plan their finances and reduce the uncertainty associated with newsroom employment.
4.3.2 Formal Employment and Benefits
Formal contracts and employment benefits were also strong attractions. Participants valued health insurance, pension arrangements, job security, and other benefits.
Participant 9, a former journalist, emphasized the importance of obtaining a formal contract and benefits after experiencing less secure employment in journalism.
The documentary evidence supports this finding. Communication positions reviewed in the study were generally associated with formal qualification requirements, defined responsibilities, and more structured employment arrangements.
4.3.3 Career Progression and Professional Recognition
Communication positions were perceived as providing clearer opportunities for professional advancement. Participants mentioned promotion, specialization, leadership responsibilities, training, and recognition.
This was particularly attractive to journalists who had experienced limited progression in newsrooms. The movement into communication therefore represented not simply a change of employer but a perceived improvement in long-term career prospects.
4.3.4 Work-Life Balance
Work-life balance was another important pull factor. Participants described communication positions as offering more predictable schedules and greater opportunities to manage family responsibilities.
Participant 12, a former journalist, explained that the more structured nature of communication work enabled greater balance between professional and family responsibilities.
This finding supports Super’s (1980) argument that career decisions are influenced by multiple life roles rather than occupation alone.
4.3.5 Professional Environment
Participants also reported greater organizational structure, professional recognition, and reduced interference in some communication workplaces.
Largely, the pull factors demonstrate that PR and communication were attractive because they offered a combination of economic, institutional, professional, and personal advantages.
4.4 Effects of Career Shifts on Journalism
4.4.1 Loss of Experienced Human Capital
The departure of experienced journalists created capacity gaps in newsrooms. Participants described the loss of experienced professionals as affecting programming, content production, editorial capacity, and institutional memory.
The problem was illustrated by Participant 3, a former journalist, who reported that the former organization continued contacting the participant because the departure created a noticeable gap in programming and content production.
The implication is that journalist turnover represents more than the replacement of individual employees. Media houses lose accumulated professional knowledge, networks, editorial judgment, and organizational memory.
4.4.2 Weakening of Mentorship and Editorial Capacity
The loss of experienced professionals also weakened mentorship. Focus group participants emphasized that younger journalists could lose access to experienced practitioners who previously served as role models and sources of professional guidance.
Participant 2 of FGD1 summarized this concern by stating: “The loss of role models weakens the profession. New entrants lack mentorship, and programs become diluted.”
This finding suggests that continued turnover may create a cumulative effect. When experienced journalists leave, younger journalists have fewer opportunities to acquire practical knowledge, professional judgment, and institutional values through newsroom mentorship.
4.4.3 Challenges to Editorial Independence
The findings also indicate concerns regarding editorial oversight and independence. Some participants associated the loss of experienced professionals with weakened editorial control.
Participant 9, a former journalist, reported that “Government sources sometimes demand to review stories before publication, undermining journalistic independence.”
This account illustrates how the loss of experienced journalists may intersect with broader institutional vulnerabilities affecting professional journalism.
4.5 Effects on PR and Communication
4.5.1 Transfer of Journalistic Skills
PR and communication organizations benefited from the skills brought by former journalists. Participants described continued use of storytelling, writing, interviewing, research, media relations, public speaking, digital production, and audience engagement.
Participant 4, a former journalist, explained: “My journalism skills in storytelling and visual communication still serve me excellently in PR. I use them daily to shape public image and produce content that resonates.”
The finding demonstrates that journalism provides a substantial skills foundation for communication careers. Rather than requiring complete professional retraining, communication organizations can employ professionals whose competencies have already been developed through newsroom practice.
4.5.2 Professionalization of Communication
Former journalists also contributed to strategic communication, media relations, content development, public engagement, and institutional storytelling. Focus group evidence suggested that the transfer of journalistic practices contributed to more structured and audience-oriented communication.
Thus, while journalism experiences the loss of skilled professionals, PR and communication benefit from the acquisition of experienced communication practitioners.
4.6 Individual Benefits of Career Mobility
Career shifts produced significant benefits for many former journalists. Participants described improved financial stability, greater access to benefits, opportunities for further education, and improved professional and personal well-being.
Participant 13, a former journalist, summarized this change as: “I went from uncertainty to stability. Now, I have a loan, insurance, and peace of mind.”
Another participant reported being able to save, support family members, and pursue further education after moving into communication.
These findings demonstrate that journalist career shifts should not be interpreted exclusively as a loss to journalism. For individual professionals, the shift may represent a rational response to employment insecurity and a pathway toward improved livelihoods.
4.7 Strategies for Retaining Journalists
4.7.1 Stronger Employment Protection
Participants emphasized the importance of formal contracts, timely payment, health insurance, pension arrangements, and other employment protections. These measures would directly address some of the major push factors identified in the study.
4.7.2 Career Progression and Institutional Support
Participants argued that media organizations should establish clear promotion structures and respond more effectively to employees’ professional needs.
Participant 9, a former journalist, asked: “Why not promote a journalist after three years of service, just like other sectors do? Retention needs structure.”
This statement captures the importance of structured career progression. Retention requires journalists to see a realistic future within their organizations.
4.7.3 Stronger Media Associations
Professional associations were identified as important actors in protecting journalists’ interests, strengthening professional standards, and advocating for better employment conditions.
Participant 1, a former journalist, stated: “Associations must amplify journalists’ voices and bring concrete cases to the government.”
The evidence suggests that professional associations should move beyond symbolic activities and provide practical support, advocacy, professional development, and employment-rights protection.
4.7.4 Institutional Investment in Journalism
Participants also emphasized that media owners and managers should reinvest in their journalists. Better management, promotion, training, remuneration, and responsiveness to employees’ needs were viewed as important retention mechanisms.
Focus group evidence similarly indicated that employer responsiveness could strengthen employees’ sense of value and attachment to their organizations.
4.7.5 Stronger Oversight
Some participants proposed stronger institutional oversight and enforcement of employment standards.
Participant 11, a former journalist, suggested: “We used to have a Ministry of Information. Its return could bring structure and coordination back to the sector.”
Regardless of the institutional mechanism ultimately adopted, the finding emphasizes participants’ perception that stronger coordination, accountability, and enforcement are needed.
4.8 Journalism as a Foundation, Not a Destination
An important finding is that former journalists did not necessarily view their movement into PR and communication as a rejection of journalism. Instead, many continued to recognize journalism as the foundation of their communication competencies.
Participant 8, a former journalist, explained: “Journalism gave me everything I needed to grow in communication. But it could not give me the life stability I needed.”
Similarly, Participant 9 expressed conditional willingness to return to journalism if employment conditions improved.
These accounts demonstrate that participants continued to value journalism while criticizing structural conditions within the profession. Career mobility should therefore be understood as movement within a broader communication field rather than straightforward abandonment of journalism.
4.9 Documentary Evidence
Document review complemented the interview and focus group findings. Job advertisements demonstrated demand for journalism and communication qualifications in institutional communication positions. Communication roles included Communication Specialist, Public Information Officer, and Communication Analyst, among others.
The documents also demonstrated the increasing institutionalization of communication functions. Responsibilities included media monitoring, digital content creation, stakeholder engagement, policy communication, crisis communication, public education, and strategic messaging.
The documentary evidence further suggested that communication positions offered more clearly defined qualification requirements, responsibilities, and professional progression than participants experienced in some journalism organizations.
Overall, the documentary findings support the interview evidence that PR and communication constitute an expanding labor market for professionals with journalism-based skills.
5. Discussion
5.1 Push and Pull Dynamics
The findings demonstrate that journalists’ career shifts are best understood through the interaction of push and pull factors. Financial insecurity, employment instability, limited social protection, difficult working conditions, and limited progression pushed journalists away from journalism. Conversely, formal employment, better remuneration, professional recognition, career progression, and work-life balance pulled them toward communication.
These findings support Lee’s (1966) Push-Pull Theory because both the characteristics of the origin occupation and those of the destination occupation influenced professional movement.
However, the findings also demonstrate that career mobility was rarely caused by one factor. Participants typically experienced several push factors simultaneously while evaluating multiple advantages associated with communication employment.
5.2 Career Expectations and Social Cognitive Career Theory
The findings also support SCCT. Participants’ repeated experiences within journalism influenced their expectations about future career outcomes. Where journalists perceived limited prospects for financial and professional development, their expectations concerning long-term journalism careers weakened.
Conversely, communication positions provided visible evidence of alternative career outcomes. The existence of formal positions, predictable remuneration, benefits, and promotion opportunities strengthened perceptions that communication offered more sustainable career prospects.
The study therefore demonstrates that structural conditions can shape career expectations and influence individual choices even where professionals continue to value their original occupation.
5.3 Career Mobility and Life Circumstances
Super’s Life-Span, Life-Space Theory helps explain the importance participants placed on family responsibilities, financial stability, and work-life balance.
Participants’ decisions were not exclusively occupational. They were also influenced by the need to support families, obtain social protection, pursue further education, plan financially, and maintain personal well-being.
Consequently, leaving journalism did not necessarily indicate declining professional commitment. In several cases, it represented an adaptive response to changing life circumstances.
5.4 Beyond Financial Explanations
Although financial insecurity was the strongest theme, the findings show that economic explanations alone are insufficient. Professional autonomy, workplace culture, recognition, ethics, workload, and career development also shaped mobility.
This is important because simply increasing salaries may not fully resolve journalist turnover. Retention requires an institutional environment in which journalists experience professional dignity, career progression, autonomy, and organizational support.
5.5 Consequences for Journalism
The career shift of journalists into PR and communication creates a significant human-capital challenge for journalism. The loss of experienced professionals affects mentorship, institutional memory, editorial capacity, and professional continuity.
The findings suggest a potential cycle in which experienced journalists leave, younger journalists lose mentors, professional knowledge becomes weaker, and journalism becomes less attractive to future professionals.
The challenge is therefore not merely the number of journalists who leave but the accumulated professional knowledge and institutional memory that leave with them.
5.6 Benefits to PR and Communication
Communication organizations benefit significantly from the movement. Former journalists bring already-developed competencies in storytelling, research, writing, media relations, content production, and audience engagement.
The movement therefore contributes to the professionalization of PR and communication while simultaneously creating challenges for journalism.
This dual effect demonstrates why journalist mobility should not be understood as a simple zero-sum process. It creates benefits in one sector and costs in another.
5.7 Skills Ecosystem Fluidity
The study’s principal conceptual contribution is the notion of skills ecosystem fluidity. The concept captures the movement of professional competencies and human capital across interconnected occupational fields.
In Rwanda, journalism and communication constitute overlapping parts of a broader communication ecosystem. Journalism develops skills that are subsequently absorbed by PR and communication institutions. Communication organizations benefit from this human capital, while newsrooms may experience a loss of experienced professionals.
The concept therefore shifts analytical attention from the individual who moves to the skills and knowledge that move between institutions.
The paradox is clear: the same skills that make journalists valuable to journalism make them attractive to other sectors.
**6. Implications for Journalism and Communication Practice**
6.1 Implications for Media Organizations
Media organizations need to treat journalists as professional human capital rather than easily replaceable employees. Retention should include written contracts, timely and competitive remuneration, social protection, professional development, and transparent promotion systems.
Media organizations should also invest in digital, multimedia, investigative, leadership, and specialized journalism skills.
6.2 Implications for Policymakers and Regulators
Policy interventions should address employment standards alongside media freedom and professional development. Where appropriate, compliance with labour standards should be strengthened, including written contracts, timely payment, and social protection.
The findings indicate that media sustainability and labour protection should not be treated as unrelated policy questions.
6.3 Implications for Professional Associations
Professional associations should strengthen collective advocacy for journalists’ employment rights and professional standards. They should also provide mentorship, professional development, career counselling, and networking opportunities.
6.4 Implications for Journalism Education
Universities should prepare students for a changing communication labour market while maintaining journalism’s distinctive public-interest mission.
Curricula can incorporate digital communication, strategic communication, public relations, multimedia production, and emerging technologies while preserving verification, independence, accountability, and public service as core journalistic values.
7. Conclusion
This study examined journalists’ career shifts from journalism to PR and communication in Rwanda. The findings demonstrate that these movements are shaped by a combination of structural push factors and attractive pull factors.
Financial insecurity, irregular remuneration, informal employment, inadequate social protection, difficult working conditions, professional pressures, and limited career progression push journalists away from journalism. PR and communication attract them through more predictable remuneration, formal employment, social benefits, professional development, career advancement, recognition, and improved work-life balance.
The shift produces contradictory effects. Journalism loses experienced professionals, institutional memory, mentorship capacity, and editorial expertise, while communication organizations gain professionals with valuable journalistic competencies. Individual journalists may also experience improved financial security, professional development, and personal well-being.
The study therefore concludes that journalists’ movement into PR and communication should not be interpreted simply as rejection of journalism. Rather, it represents professional mobility shaped by structural employment conditions and changing life circumstances.
The concept of skills ecosystem fluidity provides a useful explanation of this process. Journalism and communication are interconnected occupational fields through which professional competencies and human capital circulate.
The central challenge for Rwanda is consequently not to prevent journalists from pursuing alternative careers. Instead, it is to improve the conditions within journalism so that professionals can pursue sustainable careers while maintaining the public-interest functions of the media.
8. Recommendations
8.1 Strengthen Employment Protection
Media organizations should provide written employment contracts, timely payment, health insurance, pension arrangements, and other appropriate forms of social protection.
8.2 Improve Remuneration
Media organizations should develop remuneration structures that reflect journalists’ responsibilities, workloads, experience, and professional contribution.
8.3 Establish Clear Career Pathways
Media organizations should create transparent promotion systems that allow journalists to progress into senior editorial, managerial, investigative, specialist, and other professional positions.
8.4 Strengthen Professional Development
Regular training should be provided in digital journalism, multimedia production, investigative journalism, data journalism, strategic communication, leadership, and emerging technologies.
8.5 Strengthen Professional Associations
Professional associations should provide stronger advocacy for journalists’ employment rights, professional standards, mentorship, career development, and welfare.
8.6 Strengthen Institutional Oversight
Relevant institutions should strengthen monitoring and enforcement of employment standards and professional regulations within the media sector.
8.7 Improve Media Management and Investment
Media owners and managers should reinvest in human resources, respond to journalists’ professional needs, improve workplace conditions, and create organizational cultures that recognize and retain experienced professionals.
8.8 Strengthen Journalism Education
Universities should equip journalism students with transferable communication competencies while preserving the distinctive professional values of journalism.
9. Limitations of the Study
The qualitative nature of the study limits statistical generalization to all journalists in Rwanda. The findings instead provide contextualized insights into the experiences and perceptions of participants.
The use of purposive and snowball sampling may also have introduced selection bias because participants were partly recruited through professional networks.
The study focused on journalists who had shifted into PR and communication and therefore does not provide a comprehensive account of all possible journalist career trajectories. In addition, retrospective accounts may have been influenced by participants’ current professional circumstances.
Future studies can address these limitations through larger samples, longitudinal designs, and quantitative approaches.
10. Suggestions for Further Research
Future research should use mixed-method designs to establish the scale and frequency of journalists’ movement into PR and communication in Rwanda.
Longitudinal studies could examine whether career shifts are permanent, temporary, or cyclical and how professional identities change over time.
Comparative research across East African countries could determine whether the factors identified in Rwanda are country-specific or reflect broader regional patterns.
Future studies should also examine gender differences in journalist mobility, particularly the relationship between career progression, family responsibilities, workplace conditions, and occupational transitions.
Finally, research should examine whether former journalists continue to influence journalism indirectly through their new communication roles. Such research could provide further insight into how journalistic values, practices, professional networks, and competencies circulate across occupational boundaries.
References
Atkinson, R., & Flint, J. (2001). Accessing hidden and hard-to-reach populations: Snowball research strategies. *Social Research
Update, 33*.
Bandura, A. (1986). *Social foundations of thought and action: A social cognitive theory*. Prentice-Hall.
Bowen, G. A. (2009). Document analysis as a qualitative research method. *Qualitative Research Journal, 9*(2), 27–40. https://doi.org/10.3316/QRJ0902027
Boyatzis, R. E. (1998). *Transforming qualitative information: Thematic analysis and code development*. Sage.
Dawadi, S. (2020). Thematic analysis approach: A step-by-step guide for ELT research practitioners. *NELTA Journal, 20*, 1–12. https\://doi.org/10.3126/nelta.v20i0.27675
Deuze, M. (2009). The people formerly known as the employers. *Journalism, 10*(3), 315–318. https\://doi.org/10.1177/1464884909104937
Fouad, N. A., & Bynner, J. (2008). Work shifts. *American
Psychologist, 63*(4), 241–251. https\://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.63.4.241
Goodman, L. A. (1961). Snowball sampling. *The Annals of
Mathematical Statistics, 32*(1), 148–170. https://doi.org/10.1214/aoms/1177705148
Koch, T., & Obermaier, M. (2014). Blurred lines: German freelance journalists with secondary employment in public relations. *Public
Relations Review, 40*(3), 473–482. https\://doi.org/10.1016/j.pubrev.2014.03.004
Landis, J. R., & Koch, G. G. (1977). The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data. *Biometrics, 33*(1), 159–174. https://doi.org/10.2307/2529310
Lee, E. S. (1966). A theory of migration. *Demography, 3*(1), 47–57. https://doi.org/10.2307/2060063
Lent, R. W., Brown, S. D., & Hackett, G. (1994). Toward a unifying social cognitive theory of career and academic interest, choice, and performance. *Journal of Vocational Behavior, 45*(1), 79–122. https://doi.org/10.1006/jvbe.1994.1027
Lincoln, Y. S., & Guba, E. G. (1985). *Naturalistic inquiry*. Sage.
Marjoribanks, T., Zion, L., O’Donnell, P., & Sherwood, M. (Eds.). (2022). *Journalists and job loss*. Routledge.
Mbarushimana, J. P. (2026). From newsroom to boardroom: Exploring factors and impacts of career shift from journalism to public relations and communication in Rwanda. University of Rwanda.
Mohd, H. (2018). *Today’s public relations: An introduction*. Sage.
Moloney, K. (2006). *Rethinking public relations*. Routledge.
O’Donnell, P., Zion, L., & Sherwood, M. (2016). Where do journalists go after newsroom job cuts? *Journalism Practice, 10*(1), 35–51. https\://doi.org/10.1080/17512786.2015.1025415
Patton, M. Q. (2002). *Qualitative research and evaluation methods* (3rd ed.). Sage.
Rwanda Governance Board. (2021). *Rwanda media barometer 2021*.
Rwanda Governance Board. (2024). *Rwanda media barometer 2024: The state of media development in Rwanda*.
Scotland, J. (2012). Exploring the philosophical underpinnings of research: Relating ontology and epistemology to the methodology and methods of the scientific, interpretive, and critical research paradigms. *English Language Teaching, 5*(9), 9–16.
Stahl, N. A., & King, J. R. (2020). Expanding approaches for research: Understanding and using trustworthiness in qualitative research. *Journal of Developmental Education, 44*(1), 26–28.
Super, D. E. (1980). A life-span, life-space approach to career development. *Journal of Vocational Behavior, 16*(3), 282–298. https\://doi.org/10.1016/0001-8791(80)90056-1
Thomas, D. R. (2006). A general inductive approach for analyzing qualitative evaluation data. *American Journal of Evaluation, 27*(2), 237–246. https://doi.org/10.1177/1098214005283748
Viererbl, B., & Koch, T. (2021). Once a journalist, not always a journalist? Causes and consequences of job changes from journalism to public relations. *Journalism, 22*(8), 1947–1963. https\://doi.org/10.1177/1464884919829647
Waisbord, S. (2019). The vulnerabilities of journalism. *Journalism, 20*(1), 210–213. https\://doi.org/10.1177/1464884918809283
Weaver, D. H., & Wilhoit, G. C. (1986). *The American journalist: A portrait of U.S. news people and their work*. Indiana University Press.